
leucine synergistically, meaning the inhibition is strong only when
both are present.
IPMS (Isopropylmalate Synthase) catalyzes the leucine-specific
branch and is feedback-inhibited by leucine only.
The mutant alleles:
ahas2-1D is a feedback-insensitive mutant of AHAS, meaning valine
+ leucine cannot inhibit this enzyme anymore.
ipms1-1D is a feedback-insensitive mutant of IPMS, so leucine
cannot inhibit it anymore.
Now let's analyze growth in each medium:
(A) MS medium only – no excess amino acids present. Both mutants
will grow normally because there is no feedback inhibition occurring.
(B) MS + Leucine – leucine can inhibit IPMS in wild type but ipms1-
1D is resistant and can grow. AHAS is not inhibited since valine is
not present.
(C) MS + Valine + Leucine – AHAS would be inhibited in wild type
due to synergistic feedback, but ahas2-1D is resistant and will grow.
IPMS would also be inhibited by leucine, but ipms1-1D is also
resistant.
(D) MS + Valine only – valine alone does not inhibit IPMS, but in
wild type it may weakly affect AHAS; however, strong inhibition
occurs only with valine + leucine, so AHAS is not significantly
inhibited here either.
From this, we can conclude:
ahas2-1D will grow in (A) and (C) (resistant to inhibition by valine
+ leucine)
ipms1-1D will grow in (A) and (B) (resistant to inhibition by leucine
only)
Why Not the Other Options?
❌
(1) ahas2-1D will grow in (C) only, and ipms1-1D will grow in (B)
only – Incorrect; both mutants can grow in (A) where no inhibition
exists.
❌
(2) ahas2-1D will grow only in (D) and ipms1-1D will grow in
both (A) and (B) – Incorrect; ahas2-1D can also grow in (C) where
its resistance is crucial.
❌
(4) Both ahas2-1D and ipms1-1D mutants will grow in (A) only –
Incorrect; both are resistant and thus will grow in inhibitory
conditions (B for ipms1-1D, C for ahas2-1D).
12. Five different strains of Salmonella (1, 2, 3, 4, 5)
which can utilize lactose (Lac*) as the sole carbon
source but cannot synthesize arginine (Arg) are
mixed with five other strains (6,7,8,9,10) that cannot
utilize lactose (Lac-) and can make arginine (Arg).
These strains are mixed in all possible combinations
and plated on appropriate plates to get Lac Arg
recombinants. The following results were obtained,
where H represents 'high numbers of recombinants',
L refers to 'low numbers of recombinants' and O
represents 'no recombinants'.
On the basis of these results, the sex type (either Hfr,
F* or F-) to each of these strains was assigned. A.
Strains 2,3,6,7 are F- B. Strains 2,3,5,6,7,9 are F. C.
Strains 1,4,8,10 are F* D. Strains 1,4,8,10 are Hfr
Which one of the following options represents a
combination of all correct statements?
1. A and C
2. A and D
3. B and C
4. B and D
(2024)
Answer: 2. A and D
Explanation:
In bacterial conjugation, the transfer of genetic
material, including the lac and arg genes, depends on the sex type of
the bacteria.
Hfr (High Frequency of Recombination) strains: These strains have
the F plasmid integrated into their chromosome. They are very
efficient at transferring chromosomal genes during conjugation. The
genes closer to the origin of transfer (oriT) on the integrated F
plasmid are transferred with higher frequency.
F+ strains: These strains possess a free F plasmid. They can transfer
the F plasmid to F- recipients with high frequency, converting them
to F+ strains. The transfer of chromosomal genes occurs at a much
lower frequency compared to Hfr strains, as the F plasmid integrates
into the chromosome relatively rarely.
F- strains: These strains lack the F plasmid and act as recipients
during conjugation.
Now let's analyze the results:
High recombination (H): This suggests that the donor strain is likely
an Hfr strain with its origin of transfer oriented such that the lac and
arg genes are transferred early and efficiently to the recipient.
Low recombination (L): This indicates that the donor strain is likely
Hfr, but the genes of interest are transferred later, leading to a lower
frequency of recombinants due to spontaneous breakage of the
conjugating bridge. It could also suggest an F+ strain where
chromosomal gene transfer is infrequent.
No recombination (O): This implies that either the donor strain lacks
the integrated F plasmid (F-), or if it's F+, chromosomal gene
transfer didn't occur in the observed crosses, or if it's Hfr, the origin
of transfer is oriented such that these genes are transferred very late
or not at all within the typical conjugation time.
Based on the table:
Strains 1 and 4 show 'H' with multiple partners from the other group,
strongly suggesting they are Hfr strains with a favorable orientation
for transferring the lac and arg genes.
Strains 8 and 10 show 'H' with some and 'O' with others, also
indicating they are likely Hfr strains but with a different integration
site or orientation of the F plasmid, leading to variable transfer
efficiency of the lac and arg genes depending on the recipient.
Strains 2, 3, 6, and 7 show 'O' with multiple partners. Since they are
Lac- Arg+ and are receiving DNA, it's highly likely they are F-
strains lacking the F plasmid and acting as recipients.
Strain 5 shows 'L' with strains 6 and 7 and 'O' with 8, 9, and 10.
Strain 9 shows 'L' with strains 2 and 3 and 'O' with 1, 4, 8, and 10.
The 'L' results could indicate less efficient transfer from an Hfr with
unfavorable gene order or infrequent chromosomal transfer from an
F+ strain. However, given the strong 'H' results for strains 1, 4, 8,
and 10, and the consistent 'O' results for 2, 3, 6, and 7 as recipients,
it's more likely that strains 5 and 9 are also F-.
Now let's evaluate the statements:
A. Strains 2, 3, 6, 7 are F-: This is consistent with the 'O' results
when they are mixed with the other strains, indicating they are
receiving DNA and likely lack the F plasmid.
B. Strains 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 9 are F-: Based on the 'L' and 'O' results for
strains 5 and 9, they are also likely F-. This statement appears
correct.
C. Strains 1, 4, 8, 10 are F+: The 'H' results strongly suggest these
are Hfr strains, not F+. F+ strains transfer chromosomal genes at a
much lower frequency.
D. Strains 1, 4, 8, 10 are Hfr: The 'H' and variable 'O'/'L' results are
characteristic of Hfr strains with different integration sites or
orientations of the F plasmid.
Therefore, statements A and D are the most consistent with the data.
Why Not the Other Options?
❌
(1) A and C – Statement C is incorrect; strains 1, 4, 8, and 10 are
likely Hfr, not F+.
❌
(3) B and C – Statement C is incorrect.
❌
(4) B and D – Statement B suggests strains 5 and 9 are F-, which
is plausible but less strongly supported than strains 2, 3, 6, and 7
being F-. However, statement D (1, 4, 8, 10 are Hfr) is strongly
supported. Considering the options, and the higher confidence in
strains 2, 3, 6, and 7 being F-, option 2 (A and D) is the better fit.
The 'L' results for strains 5 and 9 could be due to less favorable Hfr
orientation in some crosses or even less frequent chromosomal
transfer from an F+ in those specific pairings, making their